Debate Club Topic: Should Studios Prioritize Creators or Brands? The Filoni vs Kennedy Star Wars Shift

Hook: Turn a real 2026 media shake-up into a ready-to-teach debate that meets your classroom needs

Teachers and student leaders: you need high-interest, low-prep lessons that build critical thinking, public speaking, and media literacy — fast. The Jan 2026 leadership change at Lucasfilm (Kathleen Kennedy stepping down and Dave Filoni taking the creative reins) is a perfect current-event case study. Use it to run a structured classroom debate on a central industry question: Should studios prioritize creators or brands? This lesson plan converts that news into a focused, standards-aligned debate that teaches research skills, argumentation, and real-world media analysis.

Why this topic matters in 2026

In late 2025 and early 2026 the media industry faced renewed scrutiny over franchise strategy, audience fragmentation, and creative leadership. Coverage pointed to Lucasfilm’s leadership change as a tipping point: reports from January 2026 noted Dave Filoni stepping into a larger creative role while Lucasfilm charts a renewed film and streaming slate. Industry analyses raised questions about balancing a creator-led vision with long-term brand consistency — a debate that mirrors broader trends in streaming fatigue, transmedia expectations, and the creator economy.

“Studios are deciding whether to foreground the individual creator’s voice or protect the IP’s long-term brand identity.”

For students, this case gives a current, media-rich example to practice weighing evidence, qualifying sources, and delivering persuasive public arguments — core college- and career-ready skills.

Learning objectives (what students will be able to do)

• Analyze how leadership and creative direction affect media franchises (using Lucasfilm 2026 as a case).
• Construct and present evidence-based arguments on the motion: “Studios should prioritize creators over brands”.
• Practice public speaking, cross-examination, and rebuttal in a structured debate format.
• Evaluate sources for credibility and relevance (news reports, box-office/streaming data, creator interviews).
• Reflect on ethics and long-term implications for fan communities and brand trust.

Standards alignment (examples)

• Common Core ELA: Cite evidence to support analysis (CCSS.ELA-LITERACY.RI.9-10.1)
• Speaking & Listening: Present information and respond to questions (CCSS.ELA-LITERACY.SL.9-10.4)
• Media Literacy: Evaluate how media companies and creators influence audience perception

Overview: Debate format and timing

Choose a format that fits class length and student experience. Two recommended options:

Option A — Team Policy (Best for 50–90 minute blocks across 3–4 lessons)

• Teams of 4–6 (Pro: prioritize creators; Con: prioritize brands).
• Structure: Opening statements (4 min each), Constructive cases (6 min), Cross-ex (4 min), Rebuttals (4 min), Closing (3 min).
• Prep schedule: Day 1 introduce case & roles; Day 2 research & build cases; Day 3 debate & reflection.

Option B — Lincoln-Douglas style (Best for one class period or smaller groups)

• One-on-one or two-on-two, focusing on values (creative autonomy vs brand stewardship).
• Tight timing: Affirmative constructive (6 min), Negative cross-ex (3 min), Negative constructive (6 min), Affirmative cross-ex (3 min), Rebuttals & closing (3–4 min each).

Classroom materials & prep

• Short reading packet: news article summaries (Jan 2026 coverage), Lucasfilm statements, select reviews of Filoni-era shows (e.g., The Mandalorian, Ahsoka), and analyses on franchise management.
• Rubrics and evidence checklists (see ready-to-use rubric below).
• Devices for research and citation tools (students should collect and save URLs, screenshots, and quotes).
• Optional: clips (1–2 minutes) demonstrating tone or brand continuity vs creator voice.

Background brief for teachers (quick context you can read in 5 minutes)

In January 2026, media outlets reported that Kathleen Kennedy departed Lucasfilm and that Dave Filoni would lead creative production alongside Lynwen Brennan. Coverage noted Filoni’s track record with serialized Star Wars TV and suggested an accelerated film slate. Analysts flagged both opportunity and risk: a single creator guiding the franchise could ensure coherent creative vision, but overly prioritizing a creator’s style risks alienating segments of fans or diluting a long-term brand strategy. Use this as your factual backbone and direct students to reputable sources (Forbes, Variety, Hollywood Reporter) for deeper claims.

Sample debate motions and prompts

• Main motion (policy): “This House believes studios should prioritize creators over established brands when greenlighting projects.”
• Value motion (values-focused): “Creators’ artistic vision should outweigh brand consistency in franchise storytelling.”
• Fan-engagement prompt: “Resolved: A single creative showrunner improves long-term fan trust more than brand-focused management.”

Starter arguments — Pro (Prioritize creators)

1. Creative coherence: A unified creative leader (e.g., Filoni) creates tonal and narrative consistency across media, strengthening long-term storytelling.
2. Audience loyalty: Fans often follow creators whose voices they trust — spotlighting creators can build deeper engagement and fandom communities.
3. Innovation & risk-taking: Creators can push storytelling boundaries; brand-first strategies may favor formula and stifle fresh ideas.
4. Transmedia synergy: A creator-led approach can align TV, film, games, and comics into a cohesive universe, improving retention across platforms.

Starter arguments — Con (Prioritize brands)

1. Long-term value: Brands are investments — protecting consistent brand attributes preserves licensing value and multi-generational appeal.
2. Risk management: Films and series are expensive; brand frameworks lower risk by using proven formulas and familiar character arcs.
3. Fan diversity: Franchises serve different fan segments; strict creator vision may alienate audiences who expect brand continuity.
4. Commercial ecosystems: Merchandising and partner deals rely on brand consistency, not individual creator preferences.

Evidence checklist for students

• Primary sources: official Lucasfilm statements, interviews with Filoni and other showrunners, box-office/streaming release notes.
• Secondary sources: reputable outlets (Variety, Forbes, Hollywood Reporter), academic papers on franchise management, trade analysis from late 2025–early 2026.
• Fan data: social sentiment samples (Twitter/X threads, Reddit), merchandise sales reports, audience retention metrics when available.
• Evaluate each source for bias, date, and methodology; annotate every claim with a direct quote and link.

Cross-examination prompts (sample questions)

• Can you name a specific example where a creator’s vision harmed a franchise’s long-term value?
• How would prioritizing creators address the needs of multiple fan demographics?
• What metrics would you use to decide when a brand must override a creator’s choice?
• How do commercial considerations (merchandising, licensing) factor into your argument?

Rubric: Grading arguments & speaking (out of 40)

1. Argument quality (10 pts): Clear claim, logical structure, anticipation of counter-arguments.
2. Evidence & sourcing (10 pts): Credible sources, correct citations, relevance and use of primary data.
3. Rebuttal & cross-ex (8 pts): Effective refutation, strategic questioning, responsiveness.
4. Delivery & rhetoric (6 pts): Pace, clarity, eye contact (or camera presence), persuasive language.
5. Teamwork & organization (6 pts): Role clarity, transitions, and adherence to time limits.

Assessment rubrics — quick teacher tips

• Give students the rubric ahead of time so they understand expectations.
• For lower grades, reduce evidence points and emphasize structure and civility.
• Use peer feedback rounds after the debate to reinforce self-assessment skills.

Differentiation & accessibility

• Struggling readers: provide a one-page pro/con summary and highlighted sources.
• ESL learners: allow written opening statements and shorter speaking turns; provide vocabulary lists (brand, auteur, transmedia, canon, IP).
• Remote/hybrid: use breakout rooms, shared Google Docs for evidence, and record debates for asynchronous assessment.

Classroom extensions and project ideas

• Write an op-ed: Students publish a 500-word piece arguing one side, citing their research.
• Brand audit: Groups map how a franchise’s brand identity is communicated across media and recommend guidelines.
• Creator brief: Students design a pitch deck for a creator-led project that also preserves brand assets.
• Podcast panel: Host a 15-minute student panel exploring the trade-offs between creators and brands.

Teaching notes on 2026 trends and ethical context

Late 2025 and early 2026 analysis highlighted a shift toward creator-driven models at some studios, paired with concerns about franchise fatigue and the need for brand governance. Encourage students to include these contextual trends in their research. Also introduce ethical considerations around fandom, creator accountability, and diversity of voices. Ask students: who should decide what “counts” as canon — fans, creators, or studios?

Examples & case evidence teachers can share

• Dave Filoni’s track record with serialized Star Wars TV helped unify tone across recent shows — use as a positive case for creator-led coherence.
• Counterpoint: past franchise installments (various studios) that changed creative leadership mid-slate and saw mixed fan response — useful to show brand destabilization risks.
• Industry commentary from Jan 2026 (e.g., trade press summaries) reporting that Lucasfilm planned to accelerate films under Filoni’s leadership — use for current context.

Reflection prompts for after the debate

• Which side used stronger evidence, and why?
• How did appeals to emotion (fan nostalgia, creator personality) compare with data-driven arguments?
• What real-world recommendations would you give a studio executive managing a legacy franchise?

Teacher-tested tips from experienced debate coaches

• Model one high-quality 3-minute opening before students prepare; seeing a sample raises performance.
• Limit the number of sources to 6 per team and require at least 2 primary sources for stronger credibility.
• Encourage students to explicitly state assumptions (e.g., “Assuming the studio prioritizes profitability over artistic risk…”).
• Use a timer and visual countdown so students practice concise, persuasive speech.

Quick troubleshooting

• If debates become too fandom-centric, refocus by asking for measurable outcomes: retention, revenue, or critical reception.
• If teams rely on opinion, require each claim to be backed by at least one named source at the start of speeches.
• For heated encounters, enforce a civility policy and use structured cross-ex to channel energy productively.

Final classroom-ready templates (copy/paste)

Opening line template: “Honorable judges, today we argue that [studio should prioritize creators/prioritize brands] because [thesis]. Our case rests on three points: [1], [2], [3].”

Closing line template: “In sum, our evidence shows that [restate strongest point]. For sustainable franchise health and audience trust, the studio should [recommended policy]. Thank you.”

Wrap-up: What students learn beyond Star Wars

This debate cultivates transferable skills: evaluating leadership decisions, balancing innovation with stewardship, and crafting persuasive public arguments — all essential in media studies, business, and civic life. Whether students are Star Wars fans or brand managers-in-training, they practice evidence-based reasoning and public speaking tied to a 2026 media industry pivot.

Call to action

Ready to run this lesson? Download the printable rubric, ready-made reading packet, and slide deck from our resource page — then tag us with your students’ best opening speeches. Try the debate in the next two weeks to leverage current 2026 coverage and keep the discussion timely. Share outcomes and we’ll feature a standout classroom in our next educator newsletter.

Related Reading

• Studio Rebrand Playbook: How to Pivot From Media Company to Production Studio Like Vice Media
• Streaming Secrets: Using Twitch Live Badges to Grow Your Magic Audience (Now Supported on Bluesky)
• Airflow Obstacles: What Robot Vacuum Obstacle-Clearing Tech Teaches Us about Aircooler Placement
• Launching a Biotech Product in 2026: Landing Page Template for Complex Science
• What Amazon Could Have Done Differently: A Developer-Focused Postmortem on New World